Changes for 2012

Among the Muses and Book of Secrets are merging, coming together to create Novel Reflections, and we're hoping you will join us in our move! Until January 1st, if you sign up for our newsletter at http://novelreflections.net, you will be entered to win a $10 eGC of your choice from one of a select group of online bookstores. We both look forward to seeing you in 2012! Happy Holidays! :)

Saturday, June 25, 2011

Bodice Ripper Review: The Wolf and The Dove by Kathleen Woodiwiss



Title: The Wolf and The Dove 
Author: Kathleen E. Woodiwiss
First Published: 1974
Setting: 1066: Time of William the Conqueror
Length: 512 pages

Aislinn, the Saxon princess known as the Dove, burns with fury as Wulfgar storms through her beloved kingdom. But the Wolf isn't just satisfied with the Dove's land: he must have her as well. She has sworn his destruction ... even as she aches to know the rapture of the conqueror's kiss. 

The Wolf

Noble Aislinn grieves as the Iron Wolf and his minions storm through her beloved Darkenwald. And she burns with malice for the handsome Norman savage who would enslave her. . .even as she aches to know the rapture of the conqueror's kiss.

The Dove

For the first time ever, mighty Wulfgar has been vanquished—and by a bold and beautiful princess of Saxon blood. He must



Holding true to the old traditional writing style of the first of published 'bodice ripper' romance novels, The Wolf and The Dove is filled with a strong declaration of descriptors that bring to life the emotions, characters, and setting of the time when the Saxon England fell to the rule of the Normans.  With that being said, I can already hear some readers rebuke the harsh and unpolictically correct treatment of characters, especially the heroine and other woman in general. It's just one of those stories that must be remembered for the period in which it was wrote during as well as the story setting itself. 

The opening prologue gives readers a myth; a parody of the  warrior Wolf and his  immortal curse to only be allowed to stir when battle arose. And now it is  the time of King William's victory over King Harold. The Norman invasion and conquering of the Saxon lands. This is what brought villain, Ragnor de Marte, to Darkenwald. Sent by the future lord of the estate, Wulfgar, to secure the lands and its people, Ragnor refuses his order and instead sets about  slaying a vast majority of it's occupants, including the Lord of Darkenwald, and taking one of the Great Hall's prized possessions, Aislinn.

Poor Aislinn of Darkenwald, daughter of the fallen Lord. This heroine seems to be constantly kicked while down. Her father has been killed by Ragnor, her mother reduced to a shriveling serf on the brink of a psychotic meltdown, the great hall is in disorder, and dangerous Norman men take whatever they will. Including the woman.  Non-consensual sex is not shoved under the carpet in this novel nor delicately glassed over. The heroine is raped by her captor, and the young servant girl doesn't fare any better. In fact, the servant girl is also subject to physical abuse. Only when the Norman knight Wulfgar arrives does Aislinn get a little reprieve -- and I mean very little. 

Aislinn finds herself slave to the new Norman master, Wulfgar, as he has taken his place as the new Lord of Darkenwald, which sets Ragnor's jealousy skyrocketing. He is enamored by Aislinn's beauty and is determined to make her his no matter what he has to do to make it happen. (Essentially Aislinn becomes the bone between two snarling dogs throughout the book.) Aislinn on the other hand is determined not to submit to any Norman. But while Ragnor makes her skin crawl, she can't help but feel a sexual awareness take hold of her each time the new lord of the manor embraces her. With each passing caress and more kinder (even though it's little in display) mastery, Aislinn finds herself wondering what it would feel like to finally give in and submit -- but only to him.

Labeled and called a bastard, Wulfgar is known for not being gentle with woman. His horrible childhood created by a spiteful mother has caused him to loose faith and trust in all females leaving him unwilling to ever let himself get emotionally attached. Yet Aislinn's fighting spirit, determination, will, strength, and even innocence appeal to Wulfgar in ways he denies up until well over the second half of the story. He is determined to make Aislinn see her place as his slave, but at the same times holds her in a twisted sense of regard.

In the mean time, Aislinn finds herself the cruel butt of jokes and purposefully put down, scorned, and abandoned by those she knows and others who have become her Norman masters. When Wulfgar's bitchy half sister arrives with their father to seek shelter, matters only seem to worsen for Aislinn. For Gwenyth's hatred and jealousy of Aislinn's beauty, admiration, and all Saxon's in general, cause Aislinn to always be the target of hurtful words and menacing schemes meant to break her. 

However, much to Gwenthy's dismay, Aislinn is not the type of hero to throw in the towel and let her sorrows of the hardships take root. She is determined to continue to help her people, and make the best of what life has dealt her. Even as time passes, she finds herself becoming more and more attracted to Wulfgar, even enjoying his company on occasion. But despite her growing attraction, she is determined not to fully submit until Wolfgar does the one thing she's ever asked of him: marry her and make her an honorable lady, not his mistress. Especially when she becomes pregnant.

In Wulfgar you'll find a true alpha hero; A warrior, dominant, broken, brooding, fighting himself and his desires, and in complete denial that he has fallen for the beautiful Aislinn. Despite his crude and uncouth misgivings, just like Aislinn, I couldn't help but fall for him. He undergoes a great deal of character growth throughout the story -- albeit slowly and sometimes frustratingly. But, nevertheless, by two-thirds way into the story, I was completely enamored by him.


Conflict runs ramped throughout this story. And while I've given a rather lengthy overview (sorry) of the main actions in the story, over the course of 512 pages there is a never ending flow of deceit, betrayal, battles, kidnapping, plans of assination, a trip to the court in London, a jousting battle to see who would finally win Aislinn's hand, and a continous annoyance at the hurtful and dispicable actions of Aislinn's mother towards Aislinn herself. Conflict drives the plot then weaves in and out and all around it as the Wolf finally finds a place to call home.

Despite the repeated words and phrases -- yes, "heaving bosom", "nay", "bastard", "copper gold hair", "her beauty", and "white, creamy globes (and thighs)" are some of most common ones -- I couldn't help but appreciate the time the author invested in creating some very heavy historic vernacular both in description and dialogue. I absolutely love getting caught up in this and feeling like I'm part of the past, watching the scenes unfold. 

The characters vividly came to life under the emotional filled prose. The hero and heroine grew in character and overtime the reader got to understand the inner workings of one dominant and brooding hero. While it may not seem so at the beginning of the story, it is apparent that Aislinn and Wulfgar make a convincing and formidable couple by the end.


With both internal and external conflict being such a large factor of the story, it's easy to say that so many elements play the antagonists. Whether it's the invasion, wars, characters, or their internal struggles and obligations, each play a crucial role in the development and conclusion of the story. One of the antagonists that has never really been mentioned in any reviews is the heroines mother! I absolutely can't say anything more for she plays a hugs role in the actions of the book, but I wonder what other readers feel about her by the end. And, the ending -- hmmm. I'd have to say that this was one of my qualms. Don't get me wrong, it's definitely an HEA, but what readers find out makes you wonder 'Aislinn went through all that for why?'


Overall, this was a fantastic read! This was the first Kathleen Woodiwiss story I've read and it certainly won't be the last! I know this review is quite lengthy, and for that I really am sorry. Even now I don't think I did this 512 page book justice! The plot, the setting, the characters, and the attention to heavy historic vernacular all completely captivated me. I felt frustrated for the heroine, annoyed by the hero, angry at the villains, and may have even swooned here-and-there when the protagonists let down their guards long enough to notice the people beneath the circumstance-created walls they had erected around themselves. The only caution I leave readers with is that some of the actions in this book may offend people -- and I'm not just speaking about the politically correct misgivings. There is rape and abuse on woman. But, I do ask that readers simply look at the time both the book was written and the time period setting itself.




This post is the first part of the Bodice Ripper Revival Weekend. Leave a comment on this review and it counts towards one entry point towards the Bodice Ripper giveaway! For more details, go here.

Make sure to check out Diana's BRR on Sunday at  Book of Secrets to get another entry point!

14 comments:

gamistress66 said...

Pretty good review, would be hard to do the book justice w/o it being a little long since the book itself is long & packed. As I mentioned in yesterday's post, this is one of my all time fave books and I read it so many times that I know it pretty much by heart (though I did forget about the trip to London till you mentioned it -- hmm, maybe it's been long enough I could read it again). 3 additional thoughts to yours --
1. I appreciated how Woodiwiss showed how Aislinn suffered in watching at watching and being unable to help (despite constantly trying) her mother's physical, mental & emotional breakdown through the book
2. enjoyed the play to the fairy tale at the start of the book that takes place when Aislinn runs off & crosses paths with the wolf during the night in the woods
3. I agree the ending, while giving us the HEA, does wrap things up a little quickly and too nicely with a big pink bow & a cherry on top (figuratively speaking of course)
I agree with your admonishment that when reading books such as this, one must keep in mind both the period of the story and when the book was written. Drives me nuts when people slam old books for not appealing to modern sensibilities -- duh they aren't modern. While they might be the great success if released for the 1st time today that they were then, neither would a lot of classics that people love (part of the reason I think "mash-ups" of those classics are popular). Likewise, the treatment of the people in the story is much in line with the era in which it takes place -- and aren't we grateful that attitude is no longer the modern attitude.

Thanks for highlighting a great old book in a positive and honest way. (and see, hard to talk about it in a short blurb) :)

Tanya said...

@gamistress66 -- Thanks so much! And I love your three additional statements -- perfectly stated!!

LOL! I completely understand the inability to keep it short when discussing this book! :) There is just so much that goes on throughout it, all of which is so closely linked to the plot (or aspects of it) that it's hard to discuss key factors without giving those pivotal moments away. Hmm.. I should have stated that in the review! :) In fact, it was extremely hard to pick out the summary points because of the abundance of events that are important, or at least note-worthy.

In addition, I feel as though I could give the plot, characters, and setting each their own independent analysis and post!

I agree with you 100% on the reality of the time period! I appreciate it when authors give me the in-my-face reality of situations when writing a historical romance. Do I want an HEA? Absolutely! I am a romance reader after all!! Do I like and condone abuse and rape of women? Absolutely NOT!!! But, the reality is it DID take place prior to woman's lib -- especially in times of ancient war. So to me it's easier for me to handle -- plus it's fiction and I always keep that in mind! :) {I could make this into a post all its own -- I think I will!)

Thanks again for stopping out and leaving a great comment!! And look, I wrote a book again! LOL!!

~Tanya

Maria said...

Great review! I haven't read this book but I do want to read it- since it's considered one of the best examples of the bodice ripper books from the 70's ....I think people forget that it's only in the last 20 years or so that things have become more "policitally" correct...there has been violence against women for ever and it would be unrealistic to write a historical book without that being included...it was what it was...

junegirl63(at)gmail(dot)com

Karen said...

I think you've done a good job with the review. I'm pretty sure I read this book when it was originally published; not really sure I'd want to read it again.

Carol L. said...

This is the one book I've wanted to read because everyone who has mentioned it has always loved it. I'm still one of the few people left, I'm sure who hasn't read it. I enjoyed your review and now I definitely have to read it. Thanks so much.
Carol L
Lucky4750 at aol dot com

Birgit said...

Stoping by from Book of Secrets and honestly, while both your reviews are great (in debth most of all) I know I'd rather read yours, as the other is slightly, uhm, well I have issues with the heftier scenes (rape), and this one sounds sexy and captivating, and you get the idea ;-) !

GFC follower

danaan at gmx dot at

Stella (Ex Libris) said...

When I started discovering historical romances and did some googling everyone kept mentioning this novel as it was one of the very first HRs and it all began with Kathleen E Woodiwiss, and I read The Wolf and the Dove back then. I remember I enjoyed it a lot, especially since I haven't read any novel set around this specific time period, I mostly read Regency or Scottish Medieval romances.

I agree, despite this not being one of the usual more tender romances, I liked the hero and thought Aislinn a strong and amazing heroine.

Thanks for this new feature, it is so much fun! :-D

lgm52 said...

Great review of a book I read some time ago...and would like to read again. Thanks for the giveaway!
lgm52(at)hotmail(dot)com

Krystal said...

I would love to read and review this novel-it sounds very intriguing. The characters will keep my attention. I enjoyed the review. I also commented on the other post's review and giveaway. Thank you! edysicecreamlover18ATgmailDOTcom

+2

Julie said...

I haven't read this book yet, but your review definitely makes me want to! I love Catherine Coulter, but I would definitely rather read this book as it seems more up my alley than the other. Thanks for the awesome review and giveaway:)

jwitt33 at live dot com

Z

lindalou said...

I love bodice-rippers! I read this book many years ago and re-read it and re-read it again. It's a classic... I actually named my son after Kathleen Woodiwiss' hero in another of her books (Flame & the Flower). Thanks for the giveaway!

lindalou said...

I'm sorry... I forgot to leave my email address to enter the giveaway. Just thinking about the Wolf & the Dove made me forget!
lindalou(at)cfl(dot)rr(dot)com

Lisa Jo @ Once Upon A Chapter said...

Great review!

I tried to read this one a few years ago based on a friend's recommendation. I had just started reading romance and had to quit when I got to the rape scene! I promised myself one day I would finish the book, because I do love Woodiwiss! I picked up another one of her books, A Rose In Winter, and absolutely loved it! Your review makes me want to give The Wolf and the Dove another shot! :-D

Lisa @ Once Upon A Chapter
lisa(at)onceuponachapter(dot)com

N S said...

I'm so glad I came across this post. I happen to enjoy bodice rippers. What some people may call dated for me it's a different experience and one I thoroughly enjoy. I like romance on the darker and passionate side, and with these novels the emotions somehow come out stronger and powerful, less repressed. The conflicts really do put you on through the emotional wringer. I have been meaning to read The Wolf and the Dove and will soon. I have read other novels by Kathleen E. Woodiwiss and enjoyed them.

Cambonified(at)yahoo(dot)com

Pages